Keurig K-Supreme Plus Review: Features, Trade-Offs, and Value
Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Keurig K-Supreme Plus review: a 78 oz pod brewer with favorites for three users and real strength control, and how it compares with the SMART version.
This Keurig K-Supreme Plus review covers Keurig's feature-rich standard pod brewer: a K-Cup machine with MultiStream brewing, a 78 oz removable reservoir, five cup sizes, three strength and three temperature settings, and saved favorites for up to three people. It is aimed at households that drink pod coffee every day and want more control than a basic Keurig gives.
We cover the exact US version, what is in the box, setup and counter fit, the daily routine, cleaning and descaling, and running costs. Then we compare it with the K-Supreme Plus SMART, the plain K-Supreme and the newer K-Supreme Gen 2, so you can tell which one fits your kitchen.
Quick Verdict: Who Is Keurig K-Supreme Plus For?
Who Should Consider It?
The K-Supreme Plus suits households of two or three pod drinkers who each like their coffee a little differently. The 78 oz reservoir brews up to 9 cups before a refill, and programmable favorites store strength, temperature and size preferences for up to three users. If you want iced coffee from pods too, the brew-over-ice option covers that.
Who Should Choose Another Format?
Skip it if you mostly brew a full pot, since a carafe brewer is cheaper per cup, or if you want espresso and milk drinks, which a pod brewer cannot make. Solo drinkers with little space are better served by a compact model like the K-Slim, and anyone who wants app control should look at the K-Supreme Plus SMART.
Version, Specifications, and What Is Included
This review covers the US Keurig K-Supreme Plus single-serve K-Cup pod coffee maker in stainless steel, part number 5000350800. It is the non-connected Plus model: the K-Supreme Plus SMART adds Wi-Fi and BrewID pod recognition, while the plain K-Supreme and the K-Supreme Gen 2 have smaller reservoirs and fewer settings.
This Keurig K-Supreme Plus review is based on the stainless steel listing because it documents every feature, including the 4 oz size, the 250-brew descale alert and the three user favorites. Other K-Supreme Plus finishes share the same core design, but check that a listing names the Plus model and not the plain K-Supreme, whose reservoir is 66 oz and which has fewer settings.
| Specification | Keurig K-Supreme Plus |
|---|---|
| Coffee format | K-Cup pods |
| Brew sizes | 4, 6, 8, 10 or 12 oz |
| Strength and temperature | 3 strength and 3 temperature settings |
| Iced option | Brew hot over ice |
| User memory | Programmable favorites for up to 3 users |
| Reservoir | 78 oz removable, up to 9 cups per fill |
| Travel mug clearance | Up to 7 inches with drip tray removed |
| Display | Digital display screen |
| Maintenance alert | Descale reminder every 250 brews |
| Grinder, milk frother, carafe | None |
The brewer is the only essential item. Pods are an ongoing purchase, and a reusable filter designed for MultiStream (five-needle) Keurig machines lets you brew your own grounds, since standard single-needle reusable filters do not fit.
Setup and Kitchen Fit
Initial Setup
Start by washing the reservoir and drip tray, then fill the reservoir and run water-only cleansing brews as the Keurig manual directs before your first pod. After that, use the digital display to set your preferences, including the favorites for each user. Setup takes a few minutes and needs no tools.
Take a moment to save the favorites properly, since they are the main reason to choose the Plus over a simpler model. Each person can store a strength, temperature and size, so the morning routine becomes pod in, favorite selected, brew.
Controls and Access
The digital display handles size, strength, temperature, iced brewing and favorites, with clear on-screen choices. Pods load from the top under the handle, the reservoir lifts out with a handle for filling at the sink, and the used pod is removed by hand after brewing. The removable drip tray sits at the front.
Working Clearance
This is a full-size brewer, so plan the space. Leave room above for the handle to open fully and for lifting the 78 oz reservoir out, and room in front to slide a travel mug up to 7 inches tall under the spout with the drip tray removed. Measure the gap under your upper cabinets before ordering.
Because the reservoir is large, it is heavy when full. Carrying it to the sink is easier than pouring water in from a pitcher, but make sure there is a clear path and a dry spot to set it down.
The stainless steel wrap is easy to wipe and looks more finished than plastic brewers, which matters if the machine sits in an open kitchen. Fingerprints show on the metal, so a quick wipe with a soft cloth keeps it looking clean.
Coffee Format and Serving Results
Verified Capabilities
The K-Supreme Plus brews K-Cup pods in five sizes: 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 oz. You can brew a stronger cup, adjust temperature across three settings and brew hot over ice for iced coffee. Keurig's MultiStream technology uses multiple streams of water, which Keurig says extracts more flavor and aroma than its K-Classic brewer with the same pod.
Results or Research-Based Assessment
This is a research-based assessment, not a set of brewing trials. Keurig's documentation establishes the sizes, settings and MultiStream design, but it cannot tell you exactly how a given pod will taste. What is clear is that the 4 oz size and the strength settings give you more ways to make a bolder cup than basic Keurigs offer, and the drink is brewed coffee rather than espresso.
Practical Limitations
The largest size is 12 oz, so a big travel tumbler may need two brews. The iced option brews hot coffee for pouring over ice, which works but is not the same as true cold brew. If you want milk drinks, you will need a separate frother, and an espresso-based latte is beyond any pod brewer.
Pod quality still matters most. A strong setting helps a mild pod, but it cannot turn a weak blend into a rich cup, so it is worth trying a variety pack to find the pods that suit your preferred size.
A useful starting point: use the 4 or 6 oz size with the strongest setting for a short, intense cup to drink black or with a splash of milk, and the 8 or 10 oz size at a medium setting for a regular mug. Use the iced option with a tall glass full of ice, since it brews a stronger, hotter cup designed to melt some of the ice.
Preparation and Convenience
Verified Capabilities
Each cup takes a pod, a button press and pod removal. With a 78 oz reservoir, Keurig says you can brew up to 9 cups before refilling, which removes the most common annoyance of smaller pod brewers. Favorites mean each user does not have to reselect settings every morning.
Results or Research-Based Assessment
There is no milk frother and no carafe. Keurig describes coffee as fast and fresh-brewed, made in minutes, and the digital display walks you through each choice. For a household where two or three people brew at different times, the combination of a large tank and saved favorites is the main convenience advantage.
Practical Limitations
Used pods still come out by hand, and you will want a bin or recycling container close by. Keurig does not publish a noise figure, so we do not make claims about sound, though any pump-driven brewer is audible while it runs. The machine also takes noticeably more counter space than compact Keurigs.
Third-party sellers currently handle most new listings for this exact model, so check the seller's return policy and confirm the listing names the K-Supreme Plus rather than the plain K-Supreme before you buy.
Registering the brewer with Keurig after purchase is a good habit with any seller, since it records your purchase date for warranty questions and keeps you informed about care instructions.
Controls and Everyday Use
Customization
The useful settings are cup size (4 to 12 oz), three strength levels, three temperature levels and brew over ice. Favorites save a combination for each of up to three users. That is enough to make a short, strong morning cup for one person and a milder 10 oz mug for another without fiddling each time.
A Complete Daily Routine
A typical routine: choose a pod, select your favorite on the display, brew, then remove the pod. Refill the reservoir every several cups rather than every cup. Empty the drip tray if needed and wipe the area around the pod holder now and then. The whole thing takes a couple of minutes per cup.
Temperature settings are worth a quick experiment. Some people prefer a slightly cooler cup they can drink right away, while others add cold milk and want the hottest setting. Saving the result as a favorite means you only have to decide once.
Multiple Servings
Making several cups in a row is straightforward because the large reservoir does not need refilling between them. Each cup still needs its own pod and its own brew cycle, so serving four people at once takes four cycles. For larger groups, a carafe brewer or a dual pod-and-carafe machine is more practical.
For a household of two or three, though, the K-Supreme Plus handles staggered mornings well: each person brews their own cup when they are ready, with their own settings, and nobody drinks coffee that has been sitting on a hot plate.
If your household sometimes wants a full pot, a pod-and-carafe machine like the Keurig K-Duo is the alternative to consider, though it gives up the Plus model's three-user favorites.
Cleaning and Maintenance
After-Use Tasks
After each brew, remove and discard the pod, or empty and rinse the reusable filter if you use one. Check the drip tray and empty it when it fills. There is no carafe or milk system to wash, so daily cleaning is light.
Periodic Cleaning and Descaling
Rinse the reservoir and drip tray every few days and let them dry fully. The machine has a maintenance alert that reminds you to descale after every 250 brews, which takes the guesswork out of scheduling. Use a descaling solution the Keurig manual approves and follow its steps; hard water may call for descaling sooner.
Wipe the pod holder area regularly too, since coffee residue can build up around the needles. Follow your manual's guidance for cleaning this area, and unplug the brewer first.
Access and Service
The reservoir, drip tray and pod holder area are user-accessible for cleaning. For anything else, contact Keurig support with your proof of purchase. Do not open the housing, and unplug the brewer and stop using it if you notice cord damage, leaks near the base or burning smells.
Purchase Price and Ownership Cost
The Complete Setup
On the listing reviewed here, the K-Supreme Plus sells new for around $160 from a third-party seller. The SMART version is around $200 from Amazon, the plain K-Supreme is around $100, and the K-Supreme Gen 2 is around $78. Beyond the brewer, you need pods; a set of four MultiStream-compatible reusable filters is around $14, and a descaling kit around $20.
Recurring Supplies
As an example, a 60-count variety pack at around $66 means roughly $1.10 per cup. Two people drinking one cup each per day would spend about $800 a year at that rate. Reusable filters with your own ground coffee reduce this considerably. Add descaling solution a few times a year; we do not estimate repair costs, since Keurig does not publish failure data.
Compared with the SMART version, the K-Supreme Plus has fewer strength and temperature steps and no app, but the running costs are the same because both use standard K-Cups. The price gap between them changes often, so if the SMART model is close in price on the day you shop, its extra settings may be worth it.
Pros, Cons, and Alternatives
Strengths and Limitations Established Above
Strengths: a 78 oz reservoir that brews up to 9 cups per fill, programmable favorites for three users, and three strength and three temperature settings with a brew-over-ice option. A descale alert after 250 brews simplifies maintenance. Limitations: it takes more counter space than compact Keurigs, and new units of this exact model are now sold mainly by third-party sellers.
When an Alternative Fits Better
If you want app scheduling and automatic pod recognition, the K-Supreme Plus SMART adds Wi-Fi, BrewID, five strength and six temperature settings. If you only need strength and iced options, the K-Supreme Gen 2 has a 72 oz reservoir for much less. For tight spaces, the Keurig K-Mini Plus review covers a far smaller brewer. Our guide to the best Keurig coffee maker compares the full lineup, and the best coffee makers guide covers carafe brewers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which exact version does this review cover?
This review covers the US Keurig K-Supreme Plus in stainless steel, part number 5000350800, without Wi-Fi. It has a 78 oz reservoir, 4 to 12 oz sizes, three strength and three temperature settings and three user favorites. The K-Supreme Plus SMART, K-Supreme and K-Supreme Gen 2 are separate models.
What extra equipment is required?
Only K-Cup pods are required. Optional extras are a reusable filter made for MultiStream five-needle Keurigs, a descaling solution your manual approves and a milk frother for lattes. Standard single-needle reusable filters are not compatible.
What cleaning does daily use require?
Daily cleaning means removing the used pod and emptying the drip tray when needed. Rinse the reservoir and tray every few days and wipe around the pod holder. Descale when the machine's alert appears after 250 brews, or sooner with hard water.
Is this model worth it for my routine?
It is worth it for two or three pod drinkers who want different settings and fewer refills. It is not worth it for solo drinkers short on space, or for people who want app control, where the SMART version or a compact Keurig fits better.
Final Verdict
Our Keurig K-Supreme Plus review verdict: it is a strong choice for small households that drink pod coffee daily and want a big reservoir, saved favorites and real strength and temperature control. The main compromises are size and the shift to third-party sellers, so compare it with the K-Supreme Plus SMART before buying. For other everyday brewers, see our guide to the best coffee maker for home, and check the current price of the K-Supreme Plus in the table above.
